We’ve all been there. You’re shopping for some brand new floors when somebody asks: “what do you have for subflooring?” And now you’re stumped, because you’re wondering—what is subflooring? And what the heck is the difference between an underlayment vs. subfloor?
Well, friend, it’s a question we hear all the time. And it’s an important one too. Because the integrity and durability of your floors—from fake wood flooring to the best bamboo flooring—are only as good as the subfloor beneath them.
Below, we’ll dive into the “what is subflooring” question. Then, we’ll explore the different materials subfloors are commonly made of. We’ll explain the underlayment vs. subfloor confusion, and finally, we’ll even show you which underlayments and subfloors are best for the most common types of flooring.
The information out there on the underlayment vs. subfloor question can be very confusing. Some articles use the terms interchangeably, but we’re here to tell ya: they’re different.
Basically, most floors have 3 parts:
Joists are the structural ribs of your floors. These heavy-duty beams run under the floors of every room in your house. In an old house, you can go into the basement, look up, and see the joists.
Subflooring covers the joists. Usually, it’s nailed to them. Together, the joists and subfloor distribute all the weight your floors take from above—running for the phone, flopping onto the heavy couch, dance parties with your dog (we don’t judge), your kids’ wrestling matches, etc.
Last is the finished flooring that you see and walk on.
Underlayment vs. subfloor—what’s the difference?
Like we said, underlayment and subflooring are not the same thing. There are some types of flooring that require a special surface between the subfloor and the finished floor. This material, between the subfloor and the finished floor, is underlayment.
Why do you need an underlayment?
There are many reasons for adding underlayment: it can reinforce the subfloor for a heavy material like tile; it can act as a sound barrier for a second-floor room; perhaps most importantly, it can serve as a vapor barrier.
But we’re going to get into that in just a moment. First, there are different subflooring materials out there in the world.
What is the best material for a subfloor?
Subfloors (sometimes called the substrate) can be made from many different materials. As we mentioned, the purpose of a subfloor is to provide stability and integrity to the finished floor. A level, smooth, and dry subfloor also makes for easier installation of nearly all types of flooring.\
Plywood is the most common type of subfloor. It’s constructed from wood veneer sheets that are glued together. It’s affordable, easy to work with, and durable.
Concrete is a more common subfloor in basements, and sometimes on the first floor of residential homes that don’t have basements (we’re looking at you, California). Remember: if you’re working with a concrete subfloor, you should always test for moisture prior to installing your new floor. Concrete can be compromised if it’s cracked or holding moisture, and underlayment will likely be recommended since it can act as a vapor barrier.
OSB, Oriented Strand Board, functions like plywood. It’s made of chunks of wood that are pressed and glued together. Think of it like a heavy-duty fiberboard.
Honorable Mention: original hardwood floorboards. In old houses, rather than a subfloor, you’ll sometimes have original wood floors that can’t be refinished. But they can make for a sturdy subfloor. Your installer will likely add a plywood underlayment layer above them.
Manywarranties tell you what kind of underlayment you need to use for your new floors. In fact, some products require you to use a certain underlayment to avoid breaching your warranty (just read some Pergo reviews for a lot of examples).
Our advice? Ask a professional for advice on underlayment requirements; your warranty may depend on it. Now, let’s look at some popular types of flooring and see which underlayments are best for each.
What’s the best subfloor for wood flooring?
If you’re buying hardwood floors, you have two options: solid or engineered planks. Each option will have specific subfloor and underlayment requirements.
Solid hardwood floor planks require a sturdy subfloor, especially if the planks are going to be nailed or glued down. Typically, the subfloor for this type of installation is plywood or OSB. And should be at least ¾ of an inch thick.
What’s the best underlayment for wood flooring?
Want to avoid squeaky floors? (That is a rhetorical question.) Use building paper! Yep, put down an underlayment of 15-pound felt building paper between a wood subfloor and your hardwood planks, and you can reduce the chance of squeaky floors and control moisture.
Also: many types of wood flooring—most often engineered products—can be purchased with click-together flooring technology. That means they can be installed as “floating floors”, which don’t actually attach to the subfloor or underlayment.
There are some disadvantages of floating floors, but when it comes to subfloor and underlayment requirements, you won’t find many. Just use the underlayment specified by your floating product and you’ll be ready to go.
What’s the best underlayment for laminate flooring?
Most laminate floors can also be installed as floating floors. And just as with engineered hardwood, your underlayment is going to depend entirely on the manufacturer’s recommendation.
Manufacturers will often suggest a plastic filament or foam layer. And some products come with the underlayment already attached. Ask your local flooring experts about these options, and remember what we said about underlayment vs. subfloor not being synonymous.
But—these qualities all depend on proper installation. Vinyl flooring can be installed as a floating floor; it can go over wood, concrete, and most other solid subflooring materials as long as they’re level, dry, and smooth. But what about the underlayment?
Vinyl is similar to laminate flooring in that underlayment recommendations may vary. For example, some products come with a foam underlayment attached, others don’t. Again, ask your local flooring experts for accurate info and warranty requirements!
What’s the best subflooring for tile?
There’s a reason the age-old tile vs.wood floor debate is still going strong: tile is awesome! And, unlike solid wood planks, tile can be installed in any room of the house.
However: subfloor integrity is super important when you’re putting down tile. As with solid hardwood flooring, a thicker subfloor is necessary to support most types of tile. In addition, it’s important that the tile is installed on an even surface that won’t expand and contract, which can cause the tiles and grout to crack or dislodge.
What’s the best underlayment for tile?
If your subfloor is wood and you want to put down tile, you’re going to need an underlayment. As Bob Vila points out, the industry standard is a concrete backer board. A common tile installation method starts with a layer of thinset (a mortar adhesive) going over the subfloor. Then, the backer board is put over the thinset and screwed into the wooden subfloor.
You can install tile over concrete, vinyl, and even other tiles. They each have underlayment considerations that depend on the subfloor material and type of tile you are installing.
If moisture is an issue, you can use a vapor barrier as well. Talk to your local flooring dealer about your warm fuzzy carpeting desires.
When should you replace your subfloor?
No matter how careful you are when maintaining your new floors on the surface, if your subfloor is compromised, it can ruin them from the bottom up.
Three common complaints are: floors suddenly becoming squeaky, floors having “squishy” spots, and floors having musty smells. If you experience any of these issues, get the problem assessed sooner rather than later! Underlayment vs. subfloor requirements may vary; these issues will always stay the same until they’re addressed.
What is subflooring? It’s the integrity of your floors.
In your quest for information on how to replace flooring has led you here, you’ve inevitably come across various subfloor considerations. The subfloor can make or break (literally, you pesky tile!) even the best floors. We hope we’ve answered your questions—whether you’re trying to understand the difference between underlayment vs. subfloor concerns, or just want to know more about what subfloor actually are.
Whatever the case, if you want durable floors that will last a lifetime—and of course you do, who doesn’t?—make sure you have the correct subfloor and underlayment.
Best known as a therapeutic horseback riding instructor and mom to a 3-year old sassy dachshund, Kim enjoys writing and a good research project. She also loves a good DIY project—probably inspired by growing up in an old Connecticut colonial.
June 2, 2020 Wondering how to replace the flooring in your home with a more scratch-resistant option? We hear you. Scratch-resistant flooring is basically a necessity or anyone with dogs, cats, or other rambunctious pets like toddlers (joking!). But with so many different types of flooring on the market, finding the perfect floor can be […]
May 29, 2020 Been browsing Pinterest for ideas on how to replace your flooring? Understandable. Wowed by pictures of concrete flooring that looks like wood? Very understandable. Everyone loves the look of hardwood, but it’s not always the right floor for the job. It costs more than many other options, it requires a good bit […]
May 26, 2020 Looking at the cork flooring Lowes sells and wondering if it’s actually worth buying? You’re not alone. Box stores like Lowes and Home Depot sell just about all the types of flooring there are, but it’s hard to know whether or not they’re worth buying. And that goes double when it comes […]